Monday, February 1, 2010

Memoirs

I mentioned before about two books I read in January. The first, Autobiography of a Face by Lucy Grealy, I would recommend to everyone. It is limited in its scope in that it centers on her memoirs regarding her childhood cancer and her thinking that her life would finally begin when her deformed face would look normal. (I, personally, would like to know more about her family dynamic, but her family has chosen to be mostly silent.) That book ends when Lucy is a young adult. Another book, Truth and Beauty by Ann Patchett, takes up where Lucy's book ended. Ann and Lucy were best friends beginning in graduate school. Ann's memoir, obviously, is from a friend's viewpoint. I found this book interesting as well as painfully honest and exasperating. I could never have been Lucy's friend--she would have worn me out!

Last week I went to a panel discussion about Ann Patchett's book. Here are a couple "gems" I found interesting. In the last 15 years the majority of memoirs about people with disabilities have been written by the people themselves, as opposed to before 15 years ago when the majority of memoirs were written by authors other than the person with the disability. (I remember in sixth grade we still had story time {we were allowed to crochet while listening} and our teacher read to us Letters from Karen written by the mother of a girl with cerebral palsy.)
Another thing that clarified for me that night is that an autobiography is a chronological accounting of a person's life, while a memoir is more focused on exploring what an event or events meant to the person, and is generally not chronological. Okay, there's a better explanation for that, but I only wrote down short notes on a postcard because we were in chairs, not desks, and I really didn't expect to be inspired to write anything down in the first place.
One thing discussed was why do Americans like memoirs so much (began with the statement that American memoirs tend to be self-centered, but eastern European memoirs center on the world around the person), and someone suggested it is similar to our infatuation with reality TV shows. Whoa, I take great offense to that--I can't stand reality TV shows (except for perhaps Dancing With The Stars). I do need to remind myself that memoirs are only part of the story of a person's life, and are the truth only as far as the author perceived the events. We all can experience the same event but re-tell it differently. Sigh. So much to think about.....

No comments: